X

TRAX LLC Contact Form

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Risk Mitigation for Coal-to-Gas Conversions

Major process changes have the potential to dramatically alter system dynamics in a power plant, and changing fuel can affect upstream and downstream pressures, temperatures, and airflow in surprising ways. When one of TRAX's recent energy industry customers made the switch to firing natural gas on two of their units, they may not have expected the extent of the impact their decision would have.

Utilities examine the impact of fuel changes carefully; the heating value, feed rate, and more contribute to the plant's function, efficiency, and generation capacity.

Making the Switch: Severe Impacts

TRAX examined several modeled scenarios for the customer's modified unit configuration, and found three significant potential problems that could cost the client millions in reinforcement costs:

  1. Along with the replacement of existing coal fuel supply equipment, the client chose to bypass or remove several pieces of unnecessary environmental equipment. When TRAX examined the new configuration, we found this change resulted in reduced system capacitance downstream of the furnace, which in turn meant the existing induced draft (ID) fans suddenly had the potential to seriously damage the unit.
  2. The utility planned to use the Primary Air (PA) fan to augment the forced draft air flow in the new configuration. TRAX found this increased the risk the higher fan pressure capacity could exceed some of the ductwork allowable pressures.
  3. In coal-firing configurations, ductwork upstream of the windbox does not usually have an excessively negative pressure rating. However, with the process changes to the unit, TRAX found deep negative excursions in this area.

Mitigating Effects

Several of the test cases TRAX investigated for this client produced severe excursions or undesirable consequences such as trips. TRAX worked with the client to develop a suite of controls strategies to reduce or eliminate the problematic behaviors. Three of the studies' key mitigating strategies included:

  • TRAX’s model testing discovered unforeseen reverse flows in one unit. This reverse flow showed the need for additional seal air with the new configuration and was promptly implemented by the customer.
  • In units with tight pressure limits for equipment and ductwork, slowing the gas valves to the rates suggested in NFPA 85 may not sufficiently minimize negative furnace pressure excursions. TRAX proposed a suite of additional control circuit modifications to reduce these excursions.
  • Further testing for these units showed that controls modification alone did not prevent excessive excursions in some ductwork. TRAX proposed reducing the ID fans' operation speed via Variable Frequency Drive (VFD).

Switching to natural gas firing can require a multi-prong approach to reduce pressure excursions and eliminate or minimize the need for reinforcement. TRAX typically examines several controls avenues to reduce the negative furnace pressure excursions, including:

  • ID fan feed-forward
  • MFT kicker
  • Negative furnace pressure override

Results

Although this client had excellent controls in place before TRAX studied the units, equipment changes still meant some scenarios were not correctly addressed in the new configuration. TRAX was able to provide mitigations to reduce the severity of the pressure and temperature excursions, allowing the client to reduce or avoid expensive stiffening or repairs, and resulting in a safe, efficient unit that better aligns with the client’s energy goals.

Risk Mitigation for Coal-to-Gas Conversions

August 22, 2025

TRAX has delivered a carbon capture simulator for a 150 MW coal-fired unit that models the capture of the full flue gas stream.  The system provides both CO2 and SO2 capture, delivering the captured CO2 to a pipeline for industrial use and underground storage.

TRAX Carbon Capture Model Included:

—CO2 and SO2 capture
—Sulfuric acid plant
—CO2 and SO2 amines filtration and purification
—CO2 compression
—CO2 pipeline and cavern

As shown below, TRAX built a modular simulation replicating the plant layout using our software, ProTRAX.  ProTRAX contains a full suite of modules specific to carbon capture functions and can model a wide variety of processes.  TRAX also virtually replicated the user interface that appears in the plant.  

Model Scope

ProTRAX is a modular software that can easily integrate multiple models for larger projects.

Schematics

TRAX organizes the simulator model to match the layout of the site or process being modeled.

Schematics

Depending on the Absorber module selected, the module can remove water vapor (H2O), carbon dioxide (CO2), and/or sulfur dioxide (SO2) from an air or gas stream.

Documentation

Each ProTRAX module is backed by comprehensive documentation, including a general description, module inputs and outputs, and mathematical formulae.

HMI

The training value of a simulator occurs in the interactive screens that replicate the site equipment.

Upon initial delivery, the TRAX simulator was used to debug control logic and processes prior to site installation and to provide operations training prior to plant startup.  There was a clear need to begin training operators as early as possible since they had multiple unfamiliar systems to learn.

Thanks to the ProTRAX simulator, our customer gained considerable insight into control functionality and system interactions, resulting in modification to some control logic and correction of simple errors.  TRAX was able to assist with controls tuning, and helped in development of initial plant Operating Procedures.

The latest upgrade brings the model into alignment with the as-built plant condition by updating and tuning the simulator models to match the current plant dynamics. In addition, TRAX has updated the simulator controls and HMI graphics to the as-built state.  Keeping the simulator aligned with the current plant condition is critical to maintaining a positive training value, and is of paramount importance to the customer.

Read MORE